This potato salad recipe is an old family recipe that my Aunt Rose made every year for our family picnic, which included about 125 relatives. The yearly picnic started before I was born and continued for decades. Each year relatives would arrive at the picnic and check the food table for Rose's potato salad. They would exhale with relief that Aunt Rose was still making her famous potato salad. This potato salad is comfort food and just the right combination of simple ingredients. Nothing fancy or gourmet, just good old-fashioned potato salad. My family gatherings were centered around food, and this picnic was no exception.
The other focus of the picnic was sports. First, there was a baseball game, which pitted the most athletic branch of the family against all the other branches. My cousins took the game very seriously. One year there was an infamous incident in which two of the elder members of my family started to get into a fist fight over an umpire's call. Next came the picnic games, which were much more light-hearted. Sometimes there was a sack race or a three-legged race. The highlight was always the egg toss. People of all ages participated, and I looked forward to seeing which cousin would pull a prank with the eggs. Most of all, the best part of the day was hanging out with my cousins.
This group was a very tight-knit band of cousins who called themselves "The Cousins Club." There were 20 original members-- my mother, her siblings, and all their first cousins. Spouses were in the club too, bringing the total membership to around 40. The Cousins Club had bi-monthly get togethers for decades. It was like a secret society because only the oldest generation of cousins was invited to the meetings. The yearly family picnic was the only exception as all ages were included for that event. These cousins weren't just relatives; they were friends who knew how to support each other and how to have fun together. Their strong bond helped them adapt as recent immigrants who lived through tough times. Today there are nine members still alive, including my cousin Sam who is the last remaining relative who was born in Czarist Russia almost a century ago.
The Cousins Club is no longer active as most of the members are gone. The original group was so tight-knit that they never let in the younger generation as new members. However, the club lives on in my heart. And the club lives on in spirit with the bond I have with the cousins of my generation. One thing that ties my cousins and I together is recipes. So, I share this recipe in honor of my Aunt Rose and The Cousins Club. This recipe is a favorite of my cousin Matt, and he has been wanting the recipe for a while. Now he and the rest of us can make this potato salad recipe and bring back a piece of the Cousins Club picnic from a former era.
Potato Salad Ingredients
One year I tried Red, White and Blue potatoes for the 4th of July. Although I think the idea is cute, my family prefers to keep this potato salad tradition exactly the way Aunt Rose created it. Some traditions you just can't change.
Aunt Rose's Potato Salad
- 3 pounds Yukon gold potatoes or white rose
- 3 celery ribs chopped in very small pieces (about 1 cup)
- ¼ cup finely grated sweet onion about ¼ onion
- 3 hard boiled large eggs chopped small
- 1-½ teaspoons regular yellow mustard or Dijon Mustard for more of a kick
- 2 teaspoons sea salt divided
- ¼ teaspoon freshly cracked black pepper
- ¾ cup mayonnaise plus up to ¼ cup more
- Wash potatoes and place them in a large pot. Add a generous amount of water, and make sure to completely cover the potatoes. Stir in 1 teaspoon salt. Let the water come to a boil. Cook potatoes in boiling water until potatoes are soft, about 20-25 minutes. Tip: if using eggs, boil them in the water with the potatoes for the first 12 minutes.
- Let the potatoes cool slightly. Peel the warm potatoes by pulling the skin off. Cut into bite-sized cubes. Place potatoes in a large mixing bowl.
- Add the rest of the ingredients on top of the potatoes while the potatoes are still warm. Gently fold everything together so that the ingredients evenly coat the potatoes. Taste and adjust seasonings as needed. Check for moistness, and add another dollop of mayonnaise, if you like it more moist.
- Refrigerate and served chilled. I like to let the flavors meld overnight and serve the next day. The mayonnaise tends to absorb into the potatoes overnight, so in the morning I usually add 1 dollop more of mayonnaise (about 1 tablespoon) and gently fold to coat the potatoes.
Love the addition of the grated onion! Thanks, Dana!
I checked out your blog because of an email my aunt Marla sent to my dad, Matt, who forwarded it on to me! We probably met years ago at one of those humongous Cousin's Club picnics or more recently at a funeral if you attended Lil or Abe's a few years back. I remember those picnics fondly but I'm sorry that I can't place you, there were always so many people and I was much younger at the time. Anyways, nice to "meet" you again here on wordpress! Thanks for sharing Rose's recipe. I love potato salad and can't wait to make this one myself. I'm sure the memories of the ball games and egg toss's will come flying back at first bite!
-Maureen "Mo" Stone
Thanks for finding me on my blog. I do remember you and your sister hanging by your father's side at the picnic, but you were very young. I know your grandmother and aunt well. Your aunt will always be a cousin I feel connected to. You resemble your aunt, by the way. I love the photos of you in vintage clothing which you posted on your blog. We share that in common-- I love vintage clothing, furniture, dishes, and recipes. If you do make this potato salad recipe, please share some with your dad to bring back that nostalgic feeling. PS- I put your blog in my reader so I can keep up with your travels. Warmly, Dana
Beautifully written. I can taste my grandma's potato salad now! Love you!
Hi Nicole- thanks for leaving a comment. So many good memories and delicious recipes.
Nancy Rose Eisman says
I want a big bowl of this now! Thanks for sharing your wonderful family memories with us. If the family picnic is ever resurrected please make me an honorary cousin.
Hi Nancy- yes, this is comfort food at it's best. And it even can be made unprocessed or vegan. 🙂 Thanks for being a reader. Warmly, Dana